profile

Rev. Maureen Cotton

'Why is he so woke?!'

Published about 1 year ago • 4 min read

My friend,

A couple emails ago I shared about why I tell sad stories on wedding days. Essentially, if you dare to tell the true story of how and why your relationship evolved into this place of getting married, then you will have a Soulful Wedding—a day of profound joy and deepened understanding + connection that lasts decades after the wedding day.

Phew—that is a big claim. And, after 15 years in the wedding industry, 11 years of marriage, and being a close witness to hundreds of marriages (both professionally and personally), I stand behind it.

In the first email I talked about why to do this. So now the question is how to do this.

First, an example of this in action. Here’s an excerpt from a ceremony last year, shared with permission and the couple’s names changed:

“For Josh and Jane, life quickly went from this giddy, falling in love, honeymoon phase to facing some of life’s greatest difficulties. Shortly after meeting, waves of loss and grief would come into Jane’s life. So much so that Jane decided she needed to tell this new guy she’s dating that something terrible has happened and she is not able to continue dating at this time. Texting seemed simple; it was just a new thing after all.
First, she writes and sends a message that explains what has happened. She apologizes that it’s probably too much for a text and too much info considering they’ve just started dating. Then she starts composing a second message saying it was nice to meet him but she can’t continue dating right now.
But,
Josh was already replying to the first message. Before Jane could finish composing the second message, she got the most compassionate and supportive text of her life.
He said he was glad that she let him know, and, ‘I just want to help however I can. Grief is a hard thing, and sometimes it helps having people around who can hold grief and not need it to go away. And sometimes, other things are called for. I just want to help how I can in this horrible time. I also know it’s early between us—only a few dates—but real life trumps any social norms around dating, I think.’
Jane is taken aback. She never finishes the second message.
Instead, she sends a screenshot of the exchange to her friend and says, ‘What is this??’
Her friend responded, ‘Who is this man? And why is he so woke?!’
To this day Jane cherishes Josh’s emotional intelligence and his huge caring heart. She says, ‘He grounds me in a way that gives me a sense of peace and wholeness I truly did not know I was missing.’
Josh’s understanding, his realness, his no-pressure presence and willingness to step forward or back as needed, all of this allowed them to continue dating even as Jane felt that she wasn’t totally herself. ”

From there, we were set up to explore how and why their relationship grew to be so deep so quickly (a truly beautiful and inspiring story).

I sit here with my hand on my heart as I reread this. As I remember the complete silence of 160 people captivated by this story, with their awe for the couple growing by the moment.

I’ve been struggling with whether I can offer a “how to” on this kind of storytelling, because for me this is all very natural. My personal and professional experiences have always integrated pain and joy, life and death. I can think of a time when I spent the morning companioning a family through a loved one's death and the afternoon photographing a newborn baby

I can’t teach this in a single email or afternoon, but I’ve created beginning questions and considerations to help you decide if you and your officiant have the desire, capacity, and skill to take on this layered storytelling.

Consider...

1. Does it serve your intention? My Create Your Ceremony course begins with couples setting an intention for marriage, then an intention for the wedding. This can be put to use to make hundreds of wedding planning decisions! Including this one. When you come up against a painful or tricky moment in your Love Story, ask yourself if telling the story will serve your ultimate intention for the wedding day experience.

(If your intention included something like wanting your community to understand or be part of the depth of your love, then the answer is likely to be yes.)

2. Is it a wound or a scar? Progressive Lutheran priest Nadia Bolz-Weber famously said (about vulnerability from the pulpit) that it’s important to preach from her scars not her wounds. Meaning, not speaking from an unhealed place that doesn’t yet have understanding.

If you bump into a painful or tricky situation that is still open and ongoing and you haven’t yet been able to make sense of it, it may be a wound and it may not be right to speak about it publicly yet. But a scar is different. While it doesn’t have to be solved or resolved or even gone from sight, it is something that has become part of your history. Ask yourself: do you have a little perspective on this moment or incident yet?

3. Can the officiant hold the complexity of the story? This is one I can’t answer for you. I think the first question is simply whether or not this person is someone who is comfortable with difficult emotional truths. Often, friend-officiants lean on a lot of humor in delivering a ceremony to make it enjoyable. Some humor is fine, of course, but a wedding is ultimately not a funny moment.

Can you picture them with some reverence or gravity in their delivery? (Participants in my CYC course or my 1:1 ceremony design can always add a 1:1 coaching session between their officiant and me, and this is something we can work on.)

Honoring the spectrum of life experiences and emotions creates joy and connection (the true point of wedding, am I right?). The difficult or painful memory is the “set up,” so to speak. What you’re going for is the aftermath—the healing, the compassion, the wisdom, the understanding, the support, the growth, the joy that flows on the heels of trying times in our lives.

I wish you a weekend full of love, my friends,

Maureen

Rev. Maureen Cotton

Reverend Maureen Cotton is an Interspiritual minister, serving the spiritual-but-not-religious. She's on a mission to revive the understanding that a wedding is transformative rite of passage. Ready to get grounded in a meaningful wedding journey? Start with the with the popular Vow Writing Retreat.

Read more from Rev. Maureen Cotton

My friend, “We should have eloped,” is a common refrain among engaged (and even married) couples. Often it’s said as a joke in the face of wedding planning stress. Yet, even as a joke it begs a really important question: “Why are we doing all this?” You’re getting married. You’re celebrating all that you and your partner have become while setting the course for what’s next. It’s a beautiful, life-altering juncture to be at and live into. Yet… Week by week your free time is absorbed into long...

about 1 year ago • 2 min read

My friends, Have you ever dated online? Or fell in love with someone you met online? Or married someone that you met online? According to The Knot’s wedding survey, 29% of millennials who married in 2022 met online, but only 15% of Gen Z. Three side notes on that stat: (1) The Knot’s survey is limited to self reports via users of The Knot, so not a perfectly comprehensive picture, but it’s the biggest survey this industry has at present. (2) Millennials are currently 26-41 years old (high...

about 1 year ago • 4 min read

My friend, Close your eyes for a moment and picture a group of people close to you. Some segment of your community anywhere from 10 to 50 people. Go ahead, I’ll wait… Got/had a vision? Question: Do you think all those people define and value marriage the same way? Almost certainly not. In a postmodern, multifaith, multicultural, individualist society, we do not have a shared definition of marriage. (Aside from the legal commitment—but guess what? Most engaged couples don’t even understand the...

about 1 year ago • 2 min read
Share this post